What is our environment? What is our role within our surroundings? How do our actions affect ecological landscapes and people’s livelihoods across the globe? What—if anything—does it mean to be “green”? This course will address these and other questions through the use of critically applied anthropology. Students participate in this blog by posting news and information and commenting on the issues through the lens of anthropology.
Thursday, April 26, 2012
Was "An Inconvenient Truth" an Overestimate of Global Climate Change?
Recently, environmental activist and author James Lovelock has admitted to being a bit of an "alarmist" when it comes to global climate change. He also stated that Al Gore's An Inconvenient Truth is guilty of the same. In fact, Lovelock is currently writing a new book in which he will argue that climate change is still happening, but nowhere near the rate he predicted twenty years ago.
Lovelock's previous publication, an article in the UK's Independent newspaper in 2006, claimed that before the end of the century, billions of people will have died due to global warming. He believed the only tolerable climates would be those of the Arctic. At the time, he believed the threat to human life and our world as we know it to be inevitable. However, six years later, Lovelock is singing a different tune.
Based on predictions made at the turn of the millennium, it was thought that the Earth would continue to heat at an alarming rate causing massive biological extinctions and drastic changes to the natural world. In reality though, the temperature over the past twelve years has remained relatively constant with no signs of spiking dramatically in the near future. As a result, Lovelock is revising his claims to say that climate change is still occurring, but at a much more manageable rate.
Do you agree or disagree that people with opinions similar to the assertions of Lovelock and Gore are "alarmists"? If so, why? Nature is so unpredictable that it is impossible to tell if global temperatures will continue to rise at the same slow rate they are now. My concern with Lovelock revoking his previous claims is that people will no longer consider global climate change an imminent threat. As a result, our population may slow the "green" movement and abandon efforts to reduce carbon emissions and other harmful environmental practices. While I admire Lovelock for admitting he made a mistake, I hope he conveys that global climate change is still a major problem in our world today.
http://worldnews.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/04/23/11144098-gaia-scientist-james-lovelock-i-was-alarmist-about-climate-change?lite
Burger King makes cage-free eggs, pork promise
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5gS_Qkp3nPqI9l6K6qenqkQFdU2hQ?docId=e439d974a5474c8f93c4b115a0a58103
According to this article, Burger King has pledged to only
purchase eggs from cage-free chickens and cage-free pork. The restaurant plans
to slowly phase-in the cage-free products until 100% of the eggs and pork is
cage-free by 2017; currently, 9% of Burger King eggs are cage-free. Burger King’s
announcement comes at the heels of other fast food restaurants such as McDonalds
and Wendy’s, who have released statements in February and March respectively
indicating that they will undertaken similar initiatives.
Thanks to the help of popular and easily accessible
documentaries like Food, Inc. that we watched in class, and (while
controversial) vocal groups like PETA, the public is developing a better
consciousness of their food and where it comes from, including the conditions
in which the animals were raised. The article states repeatedly that studies
have shown that consumers are generally willing to pay more for products that
protect animal welfare.
For me personally, the most disturbing scenes in Food, Inc. were
the ones about the conditions in which many of the poultry and livestock live
when they are being raised, especially the chickens, so I definitely support
the decision Burger King and other restaurants are making to distance
themselves from these practices. However, I don’t think that Burger King should
stop after 2017. The article emphasizes that these restaurants are mainly
motivated by consumer demand for the humane treatment of animals, but consumers
also need to be concerned about the sanitary conditions the animals live in and
the possibility for disease. I would like fast food chain restaurants address
these issues and, where needed, extend initiatives similar to this one to chicken
and beef as well.
I realize that’s a huge undertaking – the article states
that Burger King is the second largest hamburger chain restaurant in the world,
and has over 7,200 locations nationwide. Cage practices were introduced to
produce eggs and meat faster and cheaper to keep up with the demand of the food
industry. But ultimately, I think the problem is that food industry has become
entirely too over-industrialized. I’m happy to see fast food restaurants –
arguably some of the captains of the industrialization of food – developing a
better self-awareness and taking steps to support more humane agricultural and
livestock methods. The reality is that Burger King’s announcement mainly came
at the hands of consumer demand rather than any sense of responsibility for the
humane treatment of animals, so I think that it’s absolutely possible to see
more positive changes in the future, as long as we keep demanding them.
Mad Cow is Back... And Not A Problem, Apparently.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/mad-cow-disease-discovery-not-likely-to-threaten-beef-industry/2012/04/26/gIQAfgcwiT_story.html
The last time mad cow disease was spotted in America was almost a decade ago and caused an 82% drop in beef exports. Now, the disease has been discovered in a dairy cow carcass in California and nothing is really happening. The carcass was apparently not intended for consumption and so beef executives are saying that the disease’s reemergence is not cause for alarm- since the 2000s, the US has had three cases of the disease, while Canada has had seventeen and the UK has had more than eight hundred. With beef exports on the rise and the beef industry having a banner month in March, the discovery of mad cow disease in a dairy cow could be a potential threat to the industry. But thanks to regulations made after the 2006 outbreak, importers are not alarmed. Every year, the world becomes more dependent on US beef, and so the only danger even being looked at here is the potential economic danger.
Personally, I think that this is cause for some alarm, but ultimately is not too much of a threat to the food industry- which is a shame because this could have served as a serious wake-up call to the beef producing industry. Mad cow is a prion disease, meaning it can only be passed on genetically or by consuming tissue from an infected individual. Commercial cattle feed, while officially being free of mammal parts since 1997, is known to contain bone meal- that, combined with poorly-planned breeding, is how the disease spreads. Seeing as how cows are herbivores, one would assume that other cows are not part of their natural diets. I am sure that another source of the nutrients in the bone meal- calcium and protein- could be included in a healthier cattle diet that doesn’t include the remains of other cows. I do not think that the beef industry is paying attention the right set of problems here. Instead of worrying about the economic security of the industry, they should be paying attention to how the mad cow spreads in the first place and what they can do to prevent this.
Aside from the diet, testing is also a contentious matter. Small beef companies have tried to acquire the resources to test their entire herds, but the FDA, which controls the sale of testing materials, will not allow this on the grounds that it makes their random sampling test look insufficient. If mad cow is still a problem, then perhaps the random sampling is insufficient. But testing every cow at a large scale commercial feedlot is also problematic and probably impossible. I think that diseases like mad cow should cause some kind of actual reaction instead of contented economic rumblings about a record year for such a problematic industry.
A Mom Versus Monsanto
http://www.forbes.com/sites/amywestervelt/2012/04/23/leadership-lessons-from-the-barrio/
Recently, the Goldman Environmental Prize was awarded to a woman named Sofia Gatica of Argentina. This prize, which honors independent environmental activist, was given to Gatica because of her involvement with a grassroots movement against Monsanto’s use of pesticides in its soybean fields in Argentina (the third-largest producer of soybeans and of genetically enhanced crops in the world). Gatica had a child who died of kidney failure, and as she noticed the mortality rates of her area, she began a door-to-door campaign to document the health of her neighbors. Eventually, she discovered that residents of her neighborhood were 41 times more likely to get cancer than the rest of Argentina; when her discoveries were ignored by the Ministry of Health, she spurred protests that captured the attention of the global media and the global science community. Eventually, Monsanto’s spraying of herbicides was banned by a municipal order and the national government offered essentially a plea bargain- if the people wouldn’t sue, they would be given a tank for clean water. While this means that no national action was taken and the herbicides are still in use, it is at least a step in the right direction. However, this is not the end of the story.
One of the things that makes this article stand out is that it goes deeper with an analysis of the strategies used by the movement and both the positive and negative effects of this activism. It examines how individual research can be more effective than an official statement because it will highlight individual problems instead of taking an average, and also how public attention is incredibly important for a movement’s success.
The article also mentions strategies for success. In an ideal world, the pesticide use would have stopped. But sometimes what is best is not what is feasible. The clean water tank given to the region is probably not a sound long-term decision, as over time the contamination will only increase. But when an area has nothing, any step to rectify the problem must be seen as positive. To the protestors, clean water was worth more than an ideological victory.
The article also points out the long-term effects of environmental contamination and notes that even though regulations are changing, the victory is somewhat hollow for several generations. Even after cleanups and legal regulation of toxins, disease still continues to affect the populations at risk. I think that this is often overlooked when reading about cases of activism movements succeeding in getting a law changed. Writing tends to focus on the short-term, immediate effects with the supposition that things will soon heal and the environment will be as it was before the contamination. It also tends to assume that all residents are happy with the changes; yet in the affected neighborhood, people have complained that the protests have lowered property values, made things more difficult for local farmers, and have caused discrimination and employment problems because outside employers think that the health crisis might be contagious. The article shows that environmental justice is not a case of black and white morality, which I think is important. It is easy to vilify a large corporation or government agency, but for some people, the status quo does make life easier- if not better. The question then comes down to which is more important: one’s health or one’s livelihood? In cases like this, sometimes the choice really is one or the other.
Recently, the Goldman Environmental Prize was awarded to a woman named Sofia Gatica of Argentina. This prize, which honors independent environmental activist, was given to Gatica because of her involvement with a grassroots movement against Monsanto’s use of pesticides in its soybean fields in Argentina (the third-largest producer of soybeans and of genetically enhanced crops in the world). Gatica had a child who died of kidney failure, and as she noticed the mortality rates of her area, she began a door-to-door campaign to document the health of her neighbors. Eventually, she discovered that residents of her neighborhood were 41 times more likely to get cancer than the rest of Argentina; when her discoveries were ignored by the Ministry of Health, she spurred protests that captured the attention of the global media and the global science community. Eventually, Monsanto’s spraying of herbicides was banned by a municipal order and the national government offered essentially a plea bargain- if the people wouldn’t sue, they would be given a tank for clean water. While this means that no national action was taken and the herbicides are still in use, it is at least a step in the right direction. However, this is not the end of the story.
One of the things that makes this article stand out is that it goes deeper with an analysis of the strategies used by the movement and both the positive and negative effects of this activism. It examines how individual research can be more effective than an official statement because it will highlight individual problems instead of taking an average, and also how public attention is incredibly important for a movement’s success.
The article also mentions strategies for success. In an ideal world, the pesticide use would have stopped. But sometimes what is best is not what is feasible. The clean water tank given to the region is probably not a sound long-term decision, as over time the contamination will only increase. But when an area has nothing, any step to rectify the problem must be seen as positive. To the protestors, clean water was worth more than an ideological victory.
The article also points out the long-term effects of environmental contamination and notes that even though regulations are changing, the victory is somewhat hollow for several generations. Even after cleanups and legal regulation of toxins, disease still continues to affect the populations at risk. I think that this is often overlooked when reading about cases of activism movements succeeding in getting a law changed. Writing tends to focus on the short-term, immediate effects with the supposition that things will soon heal and the environment will be as it was before the contamination. It also tends to assume that all residents are happy with the changes; yet in the affected neighborhood, people have complained that the protests have lowered property values, made things more difficult for local farmers, and have caused discrimination and employment problems because outside employers think that the health crisis might be contagious. The article shows that environmental justice is not a case of black and white morality, which I think is important. It is easy to vilify a large corporation or government agency, but for some people, the status quo does make life easier- if not better. The question then comes down to which is more important: one’s health or one’s livelihood? In cases like this, sometimes the choice really is one or the other.
Discovery of Native American Artifacts Complicates Solar Project
http://www.kansascity.com/2012/04/26/3577231/discovery-of-indian-artifacts.html
Solar energy is clean, renewable, and- in the Mojave Desert at least- potentially plentiful. This might account for the federal government’s scramble to develop solar energy plants out west. One of these project is the billion dollar Genesis project, a solar plant being built in the Arizona desert.
In the rush to build the plant, however, archaeological surveys missed several deposits of potential importance, including what the group of tribes consorted as the Colorado River Indian Tribes claim is a sacred cremation site and a small deposit of charred human remains. The region’s tribes have already petitioned for a slower development process; the recent finds have been called gifts “delivered by spirits of the desert.” The Native American tribes in the region have banded together to demand that the government slow down their development movements, but the federal government and the energy firms obviously want to move forward in the face of an ever-growing need to lessen our dependency on fossil fuels.
The article points out that this is another entry in a long string of clashes between native culture and development. The desert is one of the last really undeveloped areas of the country, but the region’s tribes and advocacy groups fear that solar and wind energy projects will encroach on native rights just as other development projects have. They argue that there is not enough communication between the energy companies and the tribal leaders; instead, the companies deal with the Bureau of Land Management, an agency that has communication problems with the tribes as well.
In return, the importance of these artifact deposits has been called into question. While the tribes claim that the surveys were rushed in order to get the building started as soon as possible, none of the deposits have been large. The human remains, found seven miles from the Genesis site near a planned location for transmission towers, included small burned bone fragments, no larger than quarters, and a single tooth; the artifacts claimed as a sacred cremation site were a pair of grinding stones and some charcoal. The project had already been redesigned once to avoid the land archaeologists noted was most likely to contain artifacts.
The most important discussion in the article is that of the communication breakdown between the native tribes and the federal government. The Genesis project is considered a landmark case both for its size and expense. The developers’ worry is that the delay caused by the tribes’ protest will cause costly delays for the already expensive, partially-publicly funded project. The plans’ foundation is rocky enough already, and this continued lack of communication might sink the project even further.
I think think that building these clean energy plants is important, but I also think that if they are going to be built on native land, there should be the option for greater native involvement in their construction and use. I think a potential solution is to involve the native tribes in the plants’ development and ownership so that the profits from these plants feed back into the native tribes that control the territory. Energy companies have tried to provide financial incentives for native agencies to share detailed information about the location and importance of cultural and natural resources, but this has not been very successful. I think that it is possible that the tribes resent the encroachment of development on their land not just for the sake of development, but that external powers are profiting from the land use. Involving the tribes in this profit might help them accept these energy plants because they could put the money towards preserving their cultural resources and ensuring that the development is sustainable.
Solar energy is clean, renewable, and- in the Mojave Desert at least- potentially plentiful. This might account for the federal government’s scramble to develop solar energy plants out west. One of these project is the billion dollar Genesis project, a solar plant being built in the Arizona desert.
In the rush to build the plant, however, archaeological surveys missed several deposits of potential importance, including what the group of tribes consorted as the Colorado River Indian Tribes claim is a sacred cremation site and a small deposit of charred human remains. The region’s tribes have already petitioned for a slower development process; the recent finds have been called gifts “delivered by spirits of the desert.” The Native American tribes in the region have banded together to demand that the government slow down their development movements, but the federal government and the energy firms obviously want to move forward in the face of an ever-growing need to lessen our dependency on fossil fuels.
The article points out that this is another entry in a long string of clashes between native culture and development. The desert is one of the last really undeveloped areas of the country, but the region’s tribes and advocacy groups fear that solar and wind energy projects will encroach on native rights just as other development projects have. They argue that there is not enough communication between the energy companies and the tribal leaders; instead, the companies deal with the Bureau of Land Management, an agency that has communication problems with the tribes as well.
In return, the importance of these artifact deposits has been called into question. While the tribes claim that the surveys were rushed in order to get the building started as soon as possible, none of the deposits have been large. The human remains, found seven miles from the Genesis site near a planned location for transmission towers, included small burned bone fragments, no larger than quarters, and a single tooth; the artifacts claimed as a sacred cremation site were a pair of grinding stones and some charcoal. The project had already been redesigned once to avoid the land archaeologists noted was most likely to contain artifacts.
The most important discussion in the article is that of the communication breakdown between the native tribes and the federal government. The Genesis project is considered a landmark case both for its size and expense. The developers’ worry is that the delay caused by the tribes’ protest will cause costly delays for the already expensive, partially-publicly funded project. The plans’ foundation is rocky enough already, and this continued lack of communication might sink the project even further.
I think think that building these clean energy plants is important, but I also think that if they are going to be built on native land, there should be the option for greater native involvement in their construction and use. I think a potential solution is to involve the native tribes in the plants’ development and ownership so that the profits from these plants feed back into the native tribes that control the territory. Energy companies have tried to provide financial incentives for native agencies to share detailed information about the location and importance of cultural and natural resources, but this has not been very successful. I think that it is possible that the tribes resent the encroachment of development on their land not just for the sake of development, but that external powers are profiting from the land use. Involving the tribes in this profit might help them accept these energy plants because they could put the money towards preserving their cultural resources and ensuring that the development is sustainable.
Occupy Earth Day
http://www.dailycal.org/2012/04/22/protesters-occupy-uc-berkeley-owned-farm-in-albany/
Several members of the Occupy movement recently moved onto a tract of land owned by UC Berkeley and, as a demonstration, started to farm it. The land, a former tract farm now owned by one of the university’s housing complexes, is the slated site for a Whole Foods Market, along with a senior center and parking lot. The Occupy members say that it should instead be used for agricultural education and to prove this, they have tilled the land, begun to plant various crops, and brought in chickens. As of the evening of 4 April, there had been police warnings but no continued police presence and the Occupy members had set up tents. The protest seems to be over at this point, but its brief existence brings up a few interesting points.
Unique to this protest is the nature of the movement’s actions. They comprise a very interesting method of protest where signs are traded for scythes and chanting is replaced by chickens. If actions speak louder than words, it seems as though these Occupiers have really gotten their point across.
Another chewy situation brought to light is the disconnect between planning authorities and those affected by the land use. The Occupiers claimed that both community and campus had wanted to use the tract farm for agricultural education, but the university had been an active participant in the development plans. Furthermore, the article makes note that these plans have been developed for years. If this land is so important to the protesters, the campus, and the community, why is there no prior history of protests?
The article also focuses on the idea that a Whole Foods Market is going to be built on the site, placing less emphasis on the senior center and the parking lot. Whole Foods is a popular way for shoppers to make what they hope are sustainable, environmentally-friendly choices, even though there are often few local options. There is an element of greenwashing to the idea of this Whole Foods; it seems as though the Occupiers and the community members who had lobbied for the tract farm’s educational use might certainly think that this decreases interest in local sustainability. Is the easy ability to attain organic food more or less important than the proposed agricultural education? What is the best option here?
Earth Day, as witnessed by other blog entries, is sometimes a contentious celebration and used as a publicity stunt. It seems to me that these Occupiers are using Earth Day as a springboard to draw attention. However, I do not necessarily think that this is a bad thing; regardless of the origin and connotations of Earth Day, the public is more inclined to pay attention to matters of environmentalism thanks to the concentration of environmental messages. I think that the protest might be poorly timed, and (given the extent of the plans) ultimately futile, but I also think that this is a very interesting type of protest. Instead of just occupying the land, they tried to revitalize it and demonstrating sustainable farming practices.
Several members of the Occupy movement recently moved onto a tract of land owned by UC Berkeley and, as a demonstration, started to farm it. The land, a former tract farm now owned by one of the university’s housing complexes, is the slated site for a Whole Foods Market, along with a senior center and parking lot. The Occupy members say that it should instead be used for agricultural education and to prove this, they have tilled the land, begun to plant various crops, and brought in chickens. As of the evening of 4 April, there had been police warnings but no continued police presence and the Occupy members had set up tents. The protest seems to be over at this point, but its brief existence brings up a few interesting points.
Unique to this protest is the nature of the movement’s actions. They comprise a very interesting method of protest where signs are traded for scythes and chanting is replaced by chickens. If actions speak louder than words, it seems as though these Occupiers have really gotten their point across.
Another chewy situation brought to light is the disconnect between planning authorities and those affected by the land use. The Occupiers claimed that both community and campus had wanted to use the tract farm for agricultural education, but the university had been an active participant in the development plans. Furthermore, the article makes note that these plans have been developed for years. If this land is so important to the protesters, the campus, and the community, why is there no prior history of protests?
The article also focuses on the idea that a Whole Foods Market is going to be built on the site, placing less emphasis on the senior center and the parking lot. Whole Foods is a popular way for shoppers to make what they hope are sustainable, environmentally-friendly choices, even though there are often few local options. There is an element of greenwashing to the idea of this Whole Foods; it seems as though the Occupiers and the community members who had lobbied for the tract farm’s educational use might certainly think that this decreases interest in local sustainability. Is the easy ability to attain organic food more or less important than the proposed agricultural education? What is the best option here?
Earth Day, as witnessed by other blog entries, is sometimes a contentious celebration and used as a publicity stunt. It seems to me that these Occupiers are using Earth Day as a springboard to draw attention. However, I do not necessarily think that this is a bad thing; regardless of the origin and connotations of Earth Day, the public is more inclined to pay attention to matters of environmentalism thanks to the concentration of environmental messages. I think that the protest might be poorly timed, and (given the extent of the plans) ultimately futile, but I also think that this is a very interesting type of protest. Instead of just occupying the land, they tried to revitalize it and demonstrating sustainable farming practices.
Wednesday, April 25, 2012
Greenpeace Finds Lipton Tea in China with Unsafe Levels of Pesticide Residue
http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/04/24/us-unilever-china-quality-idUSBRE83N0AT20120424
Yesterday, word spread that Lipton tea bags sold in China contained unsafe levels of pesticide residue. Greenpeace purchased several boxes of Unilever's Lipton tea in March and sent the samples to an independent lab to be tested for pesticide residue. All four Lipton samples were found to have pesticide levels above the EU's allowable threshold. Furthermore, some of the pesticides detected are illegal in tea production according to the Chinese Ministry of Agriculture and the EU. Unilever responded to Greenpeace's study by stating that their products are safe and comply with all national standards. Historically, China has struggled to adhere to health regulations and is known for its "food safety woes." On the other hand, the American Chamber of Commerce in China and the EU Chamber of Commerce in China published reports that said Unilever China and other foreign companies are unfairly punished for health violations.
This news merits further discussion. First, it was interesting to learn that there are national standards for pesticides. Pesticides were discussed in class this week, and one point came up about the need to develop international standards for acceptable doses and concentrations of pesticides. Apparently, some standards are already in place, although given this Lipton situation, they are not effectively enforced. Moreover, this news begs the following questions: Who is in charge of monitoring companies' compliance with food and health standards, and why aren't they properly doing their job? Do you think foreign companies are unfairly punished for health violations? As a consumer, I think any company that produces products (especially consumables) which do not meet legal standards should be held responsible and punished. Ultimately, it is the public's health at stake.
What should be done to prevent similar situations like this from occurring? Or, are the standards unreasonable and therefore nothing should be done? I think the public has the right to know their food is safe to eat and their tea is safe to drink. This either necessitates more restrictions, or better enforcement of the rules already in place (most likely the latter).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
